Sunday 4 March 2012

Fostering Intercultural Communication--A Love Story

The intercultural ‘scenario’ you’re about to read is one that is relatively lengthy but very close to my heart. It is not a description of a single juncture in time, but rather a story of the seemingly unlikely union of two people.

As many couples would attest, marriage is hard work. It takes a significant amount of effort to overcome personal differences and make sacrifices and compromises. Different people have different backgrounds in terms of family structure, financial stability, education, beliefs and ideals. Interracial couples have additional, more inherent differences such as skin color, language, religious beliefs and so forth. Apart from that, interracial couples may have to deal with the added burden of negative stereotypes and derogatory comments by people who are not as open-minded to the idea of interracial relationships.
What makes an interracial marriage work? Before we go into that, let me introduce you to two very special people.

Ravinder Singh
Ravinder was born in Singapore in the late 1950’s to a humble Punjabi family. His father had come from India a few years before, and was struggling to make ends meet by starting up his own clothing business. Ravinder was English educated all his life. Even in those days in Singapore, it was mandatory for students to read a second language. At that time, Punjabi was not offered as a language, and many non-Tamil Indians in Singapore learned Malay as their second language. Ravinder is also able to speak colloquial Punjabi. Ravinder eventually made his way to NUS in the late 1970’s. Upon graduation, he began practicing as a lawyer, and continued to do so for the next 30 years.


Grace Tan
Grace was born in Singapore in the 1960’s into a wealthy Chinese family. Grace was brought up by her great-grandmother—a woman who was the epitome of class and refinement. As a young girl, Grace was an unwitting student in her great-grandmother’s home-based ‘finishing school’, where she learnt to always be gentle, well-mannered and cultured. Grace spoke almost no English while growing up as she was Chinese educated. She could speak a variety of Chinese dialects, as well as Malay.



Grace and Ravinder met each other in the 1980's. They dated for a couple of years, and when they decided to tie the knot, their decision was met with resistance from both their families. Both families held deeply-rooted stereotypes about the other’s race. Grace’s family thought that Indian men were excessive drinkers who beat their wives, and Ravinder’s family thought that all Chinese people were gamblers. However, Grace and Ravinder were determined to get married, and in April 1989, they tied the knot. 


If you haven’t already guessed it, Grace and Ravinder are my parents. As you can infer from the descriptions above, my parents come from very different backgrounds. In terms of race, language, religion, and even social backgrounds, my parents are nearly diametric opposites. So how did they manage to establish a relationship that defied the general norms of Singaporean couples in the 1980’s? Also, how did they manage to overcome the various religious, cultural and language barriers that had the potential to tear them apart?

Throughout the years, my parents have been through thick and thin together. From raising four wonderful children (hehehehe) to battling cancer, my parents have always stood by each other, and the issue of race and culture is almost never an issue. As a child, I never saw my parents as ‘Indian father’ and ‘Chinese mother’. In fact, if it wasn’t for the multitudes of questions and comments about my ethnicity, I wouldn’t even have realized that a biracial marriage was a big deal. Of course, as I grew older, I began to see things in a different light, and it finally hit me that my parents probably had to make quite a number of sacrifices in order to get and stay married. I’ve listed a few below.
 
#1: Language
When my parents met in the 1980’s, mom spoke minimal English, and she had no choice but to brush up on her English in order to hold a conversation with my father. Today, she is fluent in the language. In this respect, mom had to make special effort to pick up a language which was considered ‘foreign’ to her at the time. 
Also, while my siblings and I are all able to speak and write Mandarin pretty fluently, we know almost no Punjabi. My Punjabi grandparents have to speak to us in English, and they often express their disappointment at their grandchildren not being able to communicate with them in our ‘rightful’ mother tongue. However, my father decided that it was best for us study Mandarin instead of Punjabi, as he felt that it was a more useful in Singapore. (Most Punjabis in Singapore speak English anyway). 

#2: Religion
Another hot button issue I think many interracial/interreligious couples face is the religion (if any) in which their children should be raised. My mom was raised Buddhist and my dad was raised Sikh. To the surprise of many of my friends, both my parents are very tolerant and supportive of each other’s religions. I don’t ever recall my parents ever arguing having conflicts of interests in terms of which religion we should subscribe to. My siblings and I visit both the Buddhist and Sikh temples with my parents and I honestly cannot choose one religion over the other. 

#3: Holidays
Many people also ask me about the holidays I celebrate. I count myself very fortunate as I celebrate Chinese New Year and Deepavali (as well as many other Chinese and Indian holidays throughout the year). 

Of course there are countless other issues, but I can only describe so many. To sum up, my parents had to make quite a number of sacrifices and compromises in order to overcome their cultural and racial differences. However, I feel very blessed that I’ve been exposed to both Chinese and Indian cultures equally. My parents have made special efforts to ensure that we are proud of both our Chinese and Indian heritages. 

Today, interracial marriages are becoming increasingly common (approximately 17% of all marriages in Singapore in 2007 were interracial*) and many Singaporeans are becoming more receptive to the idea of marrying someone of a different race. Personally, I feel that this is a positive step towards racial and cultural understanding and harmony. However, there are still many who will fervently disagree. Still, interracial marriages are inevitable and will probably only increase in frequency, given the pervading forces of globalization and borderless communication. If we continue to hold on to unfounded stereotypes and unfair generalizations of different cultures, we will simply be alienating ourselves from the eventual ‘cosmopolitan culture’ of the future.

This April, my parents will be celebrating their 23rd wedding anniversary. I want to dedicate this blog post to them. Their love and support for each other has touched and inspired me, and has reaffirmed my faith that cultural and racial differences need not be a barrier to any relationship.



*References:

18 comments:

  1. WE WEEETTTTTTTTTTTTTT

    TANISHA MANOCHA THIS POST IS SO DAMN AWESOME
    LOL sorry for my outburst of emotion. As much as it is personal to you, I find myself right at home with this story because I have always heard you talking about your parent's love story. Afterall Uncle Ravinder and Aunty Grace are like my parents number 2 anyway.

    I am thankful that I have a friend like you because as you share with me your experiences and as you have had in the past as well, I have had the opportunity to learn so much about the Chinese culture and learnt to appreciate it.

    I have marvelled at your parent's sacrifices, especially Grace's (oops Aunty Grace's) sacrifices and have admired them for it. I would to wish my beloved Uncle and Aunty a happy 23rd anniversary as well.

    Thanks for this heartwarming post dey. Thank your parents for giving me the world's BEST best friend. I love you:)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for your comment Loshini! Yes I think you're probably the only one who knew this stuff before reading the blog post! :) But I don't think you've seen the pictures before ;) Glad you liked the post!

      Delete
  2. That's a long and heart-warming story!!! You are the person to explain what is intercultural, because your are living in a intercultural family!! I think it is very lucky to have parents like yours, and you are inculcated in two cultures which make you more open mind to accept different cultures from others. Indeed interracial lover need more listening, patient and care, two people have to jump over the language barrier, different religious concepts and derogatory comments from other people as you mentioned, they need to pay more attention to each other, which made them love deeply.:) Thank for sharing this touched story of you parents!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Zihao!

      Yes I agree with you, intercultural couples need to be more understanding and patient towards each other, otherwise they may end up arguing with each other because of the many differences in their cultures.

      Thank you for your comment! :)

      Tanisha

      Delete
  3. Hi Tanisha,

    This is indeed a lengthy intercultural scenario, both in writing and plot, but one that is undoubtably pleasant to read. Like your second post, you layed out the background really well and developed your story from there. Well done on that!

    Indeed, effective intercultural communication is of paramount importance in an interracial marriage, which is increasingly common in a multiracial country like Singapore. You highlighted that your parents had (and perhaps still have) to make sacrifices in terms of language and religion. I can't agree more that these sacrifices are necessary (though difficult) for them to enter and maintain a relationship. It is difficult to learn and be fluent in another language considering the fact that many Singaporeans are not even fluent in their mother tongue. In terms of religion, I am surprised that your parents can be supportive of each other since there are bound to be conflicting practices between two religions. Furthermore, I have heard of many failed marriages resulting from religious incompatibility. Thinking of the difficulties your parents have gone through, I am full of admiration for the love they have for each other.

    Your post shows that for effective intercultural communication, language and understanding, are important ingredients, but they greatest of all is love.

    Thank you for this wonderful and heart warming story.

    Joel

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Joel

      Thank you for your kind comments! Yes I agree with you, effective communication is definitely vital in an intercultural relationship. Even in Singapore, friendships can be ruined simply because of childish name-calling and insinuations based on racial discrimination.

      In terms of religion, I definitely understand what you mean when you say that marriages can be destroyed based on differing religious beliefs! I think both my parents are accepting of each others' beliefs as the teachings in Buddhism and Sikhism are not very different from each other. As my dad always says, we are all on different paths to the same destination!

      Thank you for your comments Joel!

      Tanisha

      Delete
  4. Hey Tanisha,

    I am really moved by your heartwarming post! Apologies for not knowing that you're a Chindian! I honestly thought that you were Indian! I guess this week's theme of intercultural communication must have really resonated with you since your parents are life examples!

    I agree with Joel's opinions! Intercultural communication is not the easiest thing to achieve in society, much less marriage. The sacrifices they had to make must have been excruciating at times (especially when scrutinized by their own family members). It is admirable how love can conquer all adversities! I was very moved by your mother's efforts to master a new language, and their understanding and tolerance to their respective religions.

    After reading your post I feel really guilty, because I recall telling myself that an intercultural marriage is too awkward (I never saw myself marrying anybody else than a Chinese) and difficult to maintain. This belief of mine has taken a huge hit, thanks to such a sweet love story written by the lives of your parents.

    Thank you for sharing something so personal on your blog. I can attest on behalf of everyone that whoever reads your post will feel really blessed indeed, and adopt a different perspective to intercultural communication.

    Cheers Tanisha!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. *other than a Chinese

      sorry I missed a word in the parenthesis of the third paragraph

      Delete
    2. HI Titus!

      You really didn't know I was Chindian? Hahaha. Don't worry, not everyone can tell... :)

      Actually, you're not alone in feeling that interracial marriages are awkward. In fact, neither one of my parents ever thought they would end up marrying outside their race. But times seem to be changing. I have quite a number of Chinese girlfriends who seem to be dating Indian guys! Imagine that! ;) I think we all have ideals in our minds about the type of partner we want, but no one can really predict the future. You may end up with someone you never thought you'd be with in a million years!

      Thanks for your comments, Titus! :)

      Tanisha

      Delete
  5. Omg, Tanisha, I LOVE YOUR POST!

    Two thumbs up for such a great, heart warming post. Lucky you! You get red packets during CNY and during deepavali too! Thank you for the great effort put into this post! You even did a research on the percentage! :D

    I applaud your dad and mum for their courage to pursue what they want in their life and the sacrifice they are willing to make for their soulmate. I believe it would be even tougher for them in their generation compared to others. After all, our grandparents (who I believe will be the ones that your parents will wish to seek endorsement from) are less exposed to the other races and hold greater prejudice for the other races. I am not sure if at that time the races still stay in their own areas but I believe they do. So there is lesser interaction between them and so they have less chances to interact with each other. So it's really admirable that your parents fought for the marriage despite the opposition.

    Having parents of different race which also means different culture, it is important for them to compromise and respect each other's culture. I'm glad your parents are understanding and didn't have to reach a point where one is forced to give up anything or made you or your siblings choose which path to follow. Awesome!

    I have another friend who is also a Chinese Indian and she speaks and write extremely good Chinese. She took higher Chinese when I could barely handle chinese :(

    ReplyDelete
  6. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hi Tanisha!

    Thanks for sharing your story with us! it was sweet that you dedicated this post to your parents too=)

    It's amazing how your parents overcame so many barriers before they can be together, especially despite resistance from their families. I believe the people had less freedom to choose who to marry in the past, where many marriages have to be approved by the parents. Love does conquer all odds, yeah?

    I agree that language and religion are the two major issues that make intercultural relationship more difficult to maintain. Language is after all the main tool in effective communication and religion a very sensitive topic. I'm glad that your parents are willing to accommodate each other=) I can't imagine you speaking in Mandarin though >.< haha

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hey Eileen! :)

      I'm glad you liked the post! Yes, language and religion are rather big issues when it comes to intercultural marriages, especially when children are involved. I guess the fact that my parents are Singaporean also helps, as Singaporeans are more exposed to different races and religions from a young age.

      Haha I will speak to you in Chinese soon then! :)

      Thank you for reading and commenting Eileen!

      Tanisha

      Delete
  8. Dear Tanisha, I thoroughly enjoyed this post! It's very easy to read, complete and yet fairly concise (as autobiographies go). Most importantly, however, it is passionately developed and presented. It was a real treat to learn of your family's ethnic background and to read the intelligent, insightful discussion of the barriers that your parents had to overcome not just to marry but to maintain that marriage. I especially like the way you have also made a case, indirectly, for the beauty of a relationship like that of your parents. The "proof is in the pudding, "so to speak, and anyone who knows you can attest to that.

    Thank you for sharing!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Brad

      I'm glad that you liked the post! When I first read the task description, I immediately knew I'd be writing about my folks :)

      Thank you for your kind comments Brad!

      Tanisha

      Delete
  9. hello tanisha! you're my sister from another mixture lol! anyway, needless to say, as a filindian in the house, i can totally relate. inter-racial harmonies take a lot of work just because things that other couples don't even worry about, and that are unfortunately often nothing to do with the relationship itself, can become dealbreakers.

    i can say filipinos are possibly the most global people in the world lol(mixed filipinos account for a huge percentage of filipinos) so there was little resistance on my mum's side [in fact they partook in the advertising for dad]. my dad's side, however, needed a little convincing but eventually they did relent and my parents married..so here we are with a 29th anniversary coming up in september and 2 lovely children (just keeping it factual)in tow.

    i think my parents had it easy compared to your parents. both my parents were equally poor lol. but yes, just like your mum, my mum didn't speak very fluent english as well whereas my dad was fluent in english and hokkien. and religion was not an issue because my dad was never into his birth relgiion (hinduism) so my mum happily imposed her religion on my sister and i haha. sadly, i don't reap the benefits of being in a bi-racial family like you do, though. i only celebrate christmas. bummer.

    anyway, i thoroughly enjoyed reading this post, not only because i can relate to it but because it was so easy to read given the personal touch that you imparted to it. it was a pleasure getting to know your story and a very happy anniversary to your parents, one month in advance!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Ariele!

      Dude I totally LOL-ed when I read 'sister from another mixture'. And I thought I'd heard it all! ;)

      When I first met you at the beginning of the year, I kinda thought you looked Filindian, but I didn't know for sure. Thank you for sharing your parent's story as well! Yes I agree, Filipinos are truly a global people! I notice most Filindian families are Roman Catholic though, just like your family :)

      Thank you for your comment Ariele, and for introducing to my new favorite catchphrase "sister from another mixture' :)

      Tanisha

      Delete
  10. Hi Tanisha! I think this post is amazing and I felt really touched while reading the entire story ;) I totally respect your parents' courage and determination in overcoming the numerous obstacles they encountered while forging their intercultural relationship.

    I think the union of your parents also showcases what LOVE, mutual respect and understanding for each other’s race and culture can result in. That is, enriching and blissful relationships, marriages and family ties that defy society’s view on the perceived irreconcilable differences between diverse cultures. Probably showing a little more love for each other and for people of different cultures is the way to go? Looking beyond our differences and embracing our inherent similarities and needs? Thank you for your post, you brightened my day!

    ReplyDelete